The Return of the Eliminated

Summary

Jay Mohr arrives at the house to announce a surprise - those that were previously eliminated come back. Each eliminated comic would get a vote to help determine the head-to-head match up for the remaining six comics. For the final challenge, each comic would have to pitch a sitcom with himself or herself as the star. The videotaped pitches would be shown to a focus group, who would evaluate the show. The comic with the highest-rated pitch would win immunity and a guaranteed spot in the final five. Tammy wins. In the voting, John gets the most votes. He chooses Corey. Then in another twist, they vote for a three-way head-to-head. Alonzo is chosen.

Guest stars

• Alonzo Bodden as Self - Comic
• Kathleen Madigan as Self - Comic
• Tammy Pescatelli as Self - Comic
• Corey Holcomb as Self - Comic
• Gary Gulman as Self - Comic
• John Heffron as Self - Comic